Last night I was invited over to MM’s house for dinner so that we could Discuss The Wedding. I dreaded this. Deeply. I didn’t know what she’d want to tell me, suggest to me, or ask me, but I knew that whatever it was, I was going to have to do fancy footwork while still being truthful and not cave in while not being rude. Woo! Fun!
I don’t know how much to say, because I don’t want to get all wrapped up and go on for thousands of words, but it was a very frustrating and disheartening evening. MM clearly wants us to have not a formal, but a fancy, wedding, with no expense spared to give us what we want. She also wants to tie in the location of the wedding and make it a sort of Chautauqua-themed weekend. And she is doing that thing to all of our guests that she does to me and BF, and assuming that everyone has the resources and the interest to a) spend the whole weekend there b) go out and do all sorts of Chautauqua-themed things and c) be as emotionally and literally involved in our wedding as we are.
From her perspective, I can see how it appears I am being too careless about our guests, and being too frugal with the biggest party I’m ever going to throw. But I fail to see how any of our friends and my family are going to be SERIOUSLY PUMPED about attending our little wedding. It’s just a wedding. MM explained somewhat tearfully that she cannot even express how excited her family is that BF and I are getting married; they love how happy he is with me, and it’s so terrific to them that we’ve chosen to spend our lives together. I appreciate that, but her family is the most togetherly family that I’ve ever encountered, and I just have a hard time with MM’s assumption that every person on our guest list feels the same way about families/weddings/weekends/etc. that she does.
But that was sort of the theme of the evening. BF and I had discussed that we wanted the rehearsal dinner to be just our parents and his brother – something small and intimate and extremely casual. I suggested a local fish restaurant that has gorgeous outdoor seating. MM, however, had already started to put together plans for a fancy catered dinner at one of the smaller venues in Chautauqua. She expected that we would want to invite all of our out-of-town guests to the rehearsal dinner…which is all 50 potential guests. The way she saw it, it would be thoughtless of us not to give them something to do during that evening. The way I saw it, I didn’t need or want to have two receptions. Just the one will do, thanks. We will have to negotiate this, because she explained that even if we do it my way and have a small and casual rehearsal dinner with our closest family, she and MD will probably put together a dinner for everyone else to attend, catered and at a venue.
Nngh. Anyway. She also asked me rather critically why I was putting together such a simple wedding, and didn’t I want to make it a celebration? (This really hurt my feelings; we are celebrating, this is as celebratory as BF and I get.) I think she is coming from a kind place, wanting to make sure that BF and I aren’t cutting back on any of the items in our plans because we feel we can’t afford them. But we’re not. I don’t want to spend $20,000 on a wedding. I don’t want to overdo things or spend money for the sake of spending it. There is no reason for that. I don’t know if I explained it properly, but if I did, MM didn’t get it at all, I might as well have been speaking Tamil.
So I find myself torn between MP, who want us to have a more lavish wedding than we want, and all the criticism I’ve read and gotten from outside sources, telling me that the amount I am spending is obscene and I should be ashamed of myself. Attention MP: I don’t want to be wasteful, I want things to be just right. Attention everyone else: I’m spending the amount that I think is right for where I am in my life. Attention all: I am doing my best.
She also suggested that I expand my guest list to include a few of the people that she knew had been invested in my life in the past. Her particular suggestions were good ones, but if I invite the people she suggested, the line will no longer be clear to me of who belongs on our list and who doesn’t. It’s not a matter of snobbery at all, or even money; it’s just – if I invite these people who were important to me ten years ago but whom I haven’t seen in seven, what’s to stop us from inviting half of our high school class? Or KJJ, who invited me to her wedding but whose friendship I’ve since quietly allowed to drift away? Or my mom’s best friend from my youth, who was and is an important role model to me, but whom I haven’t spoken to in more than 15 years, and who deliberately ended her friendship with my mother two years ago? I am frustrated by my inability to explain this, and also by my knowledge of MM’s perspective; she is the one, after all, who tried to pressure me into going to the funeral of my former boss’s mother, with whom I felt no connection at all. Not everyone has to go to every event of everyone they know, in my view; this is not how she feels.
The thing she told me to wrap up this topic was that she finds it hard to believe that anyone who has encountered me in the past would not feel some sort of friendly interest in me, a caring connection, that would induce them to attend my wedding. People who’ve known me want to know how I’m doing, and they want to celebrate with me at the big events of my life. Maybe I have much lower self-esteem than I thought, but this was a compliment that I thought I in no way deserved.
In fact, it reminded me of something my mother said when I was a kid that was exactly the opposite. I moved around every few years when I was a child, because my father was military and we never stayed anywhere for very long. I don’t remember what move or what expressed thought prompted my mother to tell me this particular metaphor, but what she told me was that moving somewhere is like putting your hand in a bucket of water. While you’re there, you’re immersed; your hand and the water are in the same place, and interacting, and intimate. Then, when you move away, your hand leaves the water, and the water is exactly the same as it was before your hand arrived. A few drops may cling to your hand, but the water on the whole is unmoved. As an adult I have no idea what she was trying to accomplish by telling eight-year-old me this, but at eight I was horrified. Do I actually matter that little? I asked her. Sadly, she nodded, and said that people forget each other so easily, and I just need to get used to it.
I think this idea, or some version of it, has stuck with me; I don’t see the point of inviting people to my wedding who have not been important to me in years, because why should they give a damn about me now? Our lives have moved on; we have stuck our hands in new waters. I also think that perhaps this is MM’s perspective getting the better of her again, finding weddings much more important than many other people find them; it’s unthinkable to her that any father would not want to go to his daughter’s wedding, would behave in the way my father has. She told me passionately that if she’s learned one thing in her life, it’s that you cannot depend on anything except family; and family you can depend on no matter what. Me, I have learned that I absolutely cannot depend on my parents, no matter what. They have each hurt me too much, too often. So we’ve got something of a disparity going into it.
Also, I think I unintentionally hurt her feelings very badly by all the planning I’ve done so far. I didn’t consult her at all before I started making calls, to ask her what she thought of my plans or of the vendors I was calling, and although she didn’t say anything, her tone as she continued to ask questions was chilly and sad. I did not mean to hurt her by planning without her. I did it because a) I knew what I wanted, and did not particularly want opinions, b) I wanted to get it over with, c) I didn’t want her to think I was lazy and not doing any work on the wedding, and d) I didn’t want to wait around for her to consult with every friend she has at Chautauqua to see what they thought of the vendors that I was calling.
There were other things that we disagreed about – the DJ problem, particularly – but I’m exhausted all over again just from reading what I’ve written so far and don’t want to think about it any more. I think the difficulty ahead is not going to be in the actual planning of the wedding, but in negotiating the wedding we want with MP. I think MM wants to make it an event that I can be proud of, but what she would be proud of and what I would be proud of are two incredibly different things, and she is unintentionally holding me to her standard of partying. And I’m just not her.